---

Part 3: Inside the Experience: How Consumers Live and Respond to Vulnerability

Introduction

In previous posts, we established that consumer vulnerability is dynamic and context-specific. It is shaped by a combination of personal, emotional, and environmental factors. But what does vulnerability feel like to the consumer? How does it shape their behaviors, choices, and self-concept?

In Part 3, we explore the lived experience of consumer vulnerability. We examine what happens when consumers feel a loss of control, how they cope, and the implications for their sense of identity. These insights offer critical guidance for marketers, service designers, and policy makers who want to meet consumers where they are.

Vulnerability Feels Like Loss of Control

Studies cited by Baker, Gentry, and Rittenburg emphasize a recurring theme. Vulnerability is marked by a perceived or real lack of control. Whether consumers are facing a health crisis, navigating poverty, recovering from trauma, or simply excluded from decision-making processes, they often feel powerless to influence their environment or choices.

For example:

• Homeless consumers report not being in control of where they sleep, what they eat, or how they are perceived. However, they still engage in adaptive strategies. These strategies include scavenging or forming supportive communities.
• Women undergoing breast cancer treatment describe losing control over their bodies, routines, and appearance, which disrupts their sense of identity.
• Consumers with disabilities often feel vulnerable in retail environments. Their vulnerability is not due to their impairment. Instead, physical spaces and social signals limit their autonomy.

These examples show that vulnerability does not stem from personal weakness, but from disempowering conditions that restrict consumer agency.

Coping Strategies: How Consumers Respond

Consumers are not passive victims of vulnerability. They engage in a variety of cognitive, emotional, and behavioral strategies to regain control or reduce harm.

1. Cognitive and emotional coping
   • Distancing: Reframing their experience to separate themselves from negative stereotypes or assumptions (e.g. “I’m not like other welfare recipients”).
   • Disattaching: Emotionally detaching from possessions, relationships, or identities that reinforce a vulnerable state.
   • Fantasy and aspiration: Using imagination to mentally escape present conditions. It allows envisioning a better future. This is often seen in children or individuals in crisis.
   • Emotional regulation: Managing responses to stress or frustration, such as elderly consumers coping with health-related stress by focusing on emotional well-being.
2. Behavioral coping
   • Social support: Seeking help from friends, family, community shelters, or service providers.
   • Symbolic actions: Taking steps like disposing of “cancer clothes” after recovery to signify identity renewal.
   • Consumer resistance: Rejecting stigmatizing products, expressing identity through countercultural consumption, or educating others through daily interactions.
   • Deception and masking: Using humor, imitation, or concealment to navigate systems (e.g. low-literate consumers masking their difficulties).

These coping strategies often reflect resourcefulness and resilience, even in the face of persistent barriers.

When Coping Fails: Learned Helplessness

While many consumers adapt and resist, some experience vulnerability so overwhelming that coping breaks down. This can lead to learned helplessness, a psychological state in which individuals no longer believe their actions can improve their situation.

Examples include:

• People living in chronic poverty who feel trapped and demotivated.
• Consumers battling addiction who lose confidence in their capacity for change.
• Individuals repeatedly denied fair treatment who begin to internalize marginalization.

Learned helplessness undermines both identity and agency. When experienced over time, it can erode motivation, self-worth, and belief in a better future.

The Identity Implications of Vulnerability

Consumer vulnerability is deeply tied to self-concept—how people see themselves and their place in the world.

According to Baker et al., vulnerability impacts several aspects of identity:

• Perceived competence: Am I able to function effectively in this environment?
• Social acceptance: Am I seen as “normal” or respected by others?
• Self-continuity and control: Can I maintain or rebuild who I am?
• Security of the extended self: Are my possessions, family, or social roles stable?

These questions become acute during times of disorientation or change. But just as identity can be disrupted, it can also be reconstructed. Consumption plays a role in that process. From symbolic purchases to new rituals of self-expression, consumers use the marketplace to reassert control and reaffirm their identity—even in small ways.

Why This Matters for Marketers

Understanding how consumers feel when they experience vulnerability helps shift marketing practice away from assumptions and toward empathy.

Marketers should:

• Recognize that loss of control is central to vulnerability.
• Create environments and messages that restore autonomy.
• Support diverse forms of identity expression and renewal.
• Be alert to the signs of resistance and resilience in consumer behavior.
• Avoid reinforcing stereotypes or inadvertently promoting learned helplessness.

Looking Ahead

In the final part of this series, we will examine how businesses and policy makers can move beyond acknowledgment to action. We will explore what it means to design systems that empower consumers, reduce situational vulnerability, and support long-term consumer well-being.

Reference

Baker, S. M., Gentry, J. W., & Rittenburg, T. L. (2005). Building Understanding of the Domain of Consumer Vulnerability. Journal of Macromarketing, 25(2), 128–139.

---